Let’s all face reality.
Many studies have shown that our students are spending more time on their
computers each day than they are sleeping.
They are on Facebook and tweeting simultaneously and switching back and
forth between social networking sites and YouTube. We as educators try to bring them into the
world of academics we are trying to create and implement into their lives. However, it is starting to look like we should
take a different approach in motivating our students.
I would argue that students are more
comfortable with the layout and functions of Facebook than they are with the operation
of Microsoft Word. So why do we insist
on making them write a 3-page double spaced paper once a week using Microsoft Word. While these
programs were designed to make the process of writing easier, it can sometimes
hinder the performance of a student.
Students write and have to worry about formatting, page length, font, alignment
and much more. This added stress depreciates
the value of their content and even more important, their creativity. Microsoft Word is just the medium a student
has to express their thought, but so is Facebook.
Having said all of this, it is important that the
assignment given to the students still has some structure. Boromir, from Lord of the Rings says it best:
He is correct. If the assignment is not purposeful, students will get distracted or not gain anything from it. Their
writing should satisfy the assignment’s underlying intent. This is the responsibility of the
teacher. What do you want your students
to get out of the assignment? Are you
trying to gain an understanding of their knowledge of a topic? The assignment should not be blindly thrown
together because you think it is easy.
Thoughtful and creative assignments are great, but ones that also impact
the student by challenging them to critically think and problem solve are the
ones that stay with them for a lifetime.
Tony, I cannot agree with you more. We should definitely incorporate mediums students are comfortable with into their homework. Unfortunately, as we have learned before not all students have access to these mediums. So what do we do then? Do we give students the options of doing their work one way or another? We definitely cannot penalize them for not having access to certain mediums!
ReplyDeleteThat is a whole other argument. But as far as using Facebook to help them write their papers, I completely agree. I always have my phone on me and and working on different things. I actually find it easier to type up long posts or writings on my phone and iPad than I do a computer. It's funny I know, but I remember in college typing up a whole French paper on my phone in another class. Now that is dedication.